Chosen Solution
So I replaced my charge port on my iPhone 4S and now that works like a charm, but now my home button does not work at all. Any thoghts?
Did you reconnect the home button flex to the new charge port connector? Or home button flex is not connected correctly. Home button flex could have been damaged during repair. New charge port may be faulty.
Could be a monkey wrench stuck in there. Or a yard gnome. But seriously, EXACTLY the same symptoms here.